1. Leibniz-Zentrum Moderner Orient
  2. Publikationen
  3. Publikationsregister
  4. Why is there no IR scholarship on intelligence agencies?
Publikationsregister

Hoffmann, Sophia

Why is there no IR scholarship on intelligence agencies?

Some ideas for a new approach

Leibniz-Zentrum Moderner Orient, Berlin, 2019
Reihe: ZMO Working Papers 23

14 S.

ISSN/ISBN 2191-3897
DOI: urn:nbn:de:101:1-2019091210563924185640
Abstract

Scholarship on intelligence studies suffers three key limitations: 1) it fails to grasp that the knowledge-production of agencies is value-laden and thus political in itself; 2) scholarship disre-gards most of the non-English speaking world and 3) focuses nearly exclusively on foreign intel-ligence. I suggest that these limitations are due to a broader theoretical poverty of intelligence stu-dies, and present three concepts through which a richer analysis may emerge: 1) »security« in the sense of understanding the meaning of secu-rity that intelligence agencies use as a basis for operating; 2) »secrecy« to investigate the concrete measures that agencies use to create and manage secrecy and 3) »bureaucracy« to investigate the day-to-day work done by the bulk of intelligence employees. These concepts turn the gaze towards the concrete, institutional processes of intelli-gence production, rather than towards abstract models such as the intelligence cycle, which do-minate current scholarship. Intelligence studies needs to borrow from the rich tradition of orga-nizational sociology and critical IR to develop a more thorough understanding of what intelli-gence agencies actually do, and what their effect on international politics is.

Link dazu PDF